Level of trainees	No evaluation	Kirkpatrick Level 1 (Reaction)	Kirkpatrick Level 2 (Learning)	Kirkpatrick Level 3 (Behaviour)	Kirkpatrick Level 4 (Results)
Undergraduate medical education	Davenport et al. 2005,35 Kerr et al. 2001,33 Luther, Ohl and Hicks 2013,25 Pulcini et al. 2015,9 Shankar et al. 2011,26 Wright and Jain 200434	Beylefeld and Struwig 2007,38 Chuenchom, et al. 2016, 17 Haque et al. 2016, 18 Hoque, Mostafa & Haque, 2016, 24 Marwick and Nathwani 2007,39 Minen et al. 2010,36 Valente et al. 200937	Huang et al. 2013,40 Marwick and Nathwani, 2007,39 Valente et al. 200937
Postgraduate medical education	Brennan and Mattick  2013,52 Philp, Wilford and Low 198651	Bannan et al. 2009,55 Gharbi et al. 2016, 16 Nifakos, Tomson and Zary 2014,53 Nand et al. 2016, 68 Temte et al. 1999,61 Welch et al. 200054	Faryna, Wegowske and Goldenberg 1987,56 Feucht et al. 2003,57 Ikai et al. 2012,58 Pisano et al. 2016, 67 Rawson et al. 201615	Légaré et al 2011,59 Irfan et al. 2015,65 Main and Koerner 2012,60 McLellan et al. 2016, 66 Temte et al. 1999,61 Welch et al. 2000,54 Zwar, Gordon and Sanson-Fisher 1995,62 Zwar et al. 1999,63 Lee et al. 201464
Mixed undergraduate and postgraduate medical education	Davey et al 1993,29 Ghafur 2013,41 Greenwood 1998,44 Lee et al. 2013,45 Lee et al. 2015,46 McNulty, Cookson and Lewis 2012,43 Pulcini and Gyssens 201342		Dawson, Bennett and Ongley, 2010,47 Zamin, Pitre and Conly, 199748	De Souza et al. 2006,50 Thamlikitkul et al. 199849	Thamlikitkul et al. 199849
Unspecified	Davey et al. 2007,71 Le Normand et al. 199469		Bain 198470

Int J Med Educ. 2017; 8:353-374; doi: 10.5116/ijme.59ba.2d47