Excellent emergency medicine educators adapt teaching methods to learner experience level and patient acuity
Kristi H. Grall1, Ilene B. Harris2, Deborah Simpson3, Mark Gelula2, Jaime Butler4 and Edward P. Callahan5
1Department of Emergency Medicine, University of Arizona, USA
2Department of Medical Education, University of Illinois at Chicago, USA
3Academic Administration, Aurora Health Care-Milwaukee, USA
4Department of Emergency Medicine, Providence Alaska Medical Center/University of Washington-Anchorage, USA
5Department of Emergency Medicine, Medical College of Wisconsin, USA
Submitted: 20/11/2012; Accepted: 04/05/2013; Published: 27/05/2013
Int J Med Educ. 2013; 4:101-106; doi: 10.5116/ijme.5184.d71f
© 2013 Kristi H. Grall et al. This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License which permits unrestricted use of work provided the original work is properly cited. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0
Objectives: This study investigates whether instructional methods used by excellent emergency medicine residency teachers change with changing conditions of learner level of training, patient acuity and department census.
Methods: Four excellent, purposively selected, emergency medicine teachers consented to participate in this non-participant observational study. Teachers were observed for 32 hours in the emergency department, using a structured observation form focused on: teaching methods used, context learner level of training, emergency department patient census and patients' illness severity. Data was analyzed qualitatively using constant comparative analysis.
Results: Fifteen (15) categories of teaching methods were observed. The 4 most frequently observed methods were: Questioning (used in 47% of teaching encounters), Advice Giving (33%), Limited Teaching Points (31%) and Patient Updates (22%). Patient Updates were more often used with senior residents. Multiple methods were used in most encounters. Teaching methods did not vary significantly with increased emergency department volume, but faculty and residents relied more heavily on a single method of teaching per encounter as patient acuity increased to Triage levels One and Two.
Conclusions: Excellent emergency medicine teachers teaching methods were classified into 15 categories. They typically rely heavily on four methods, adapting to resident training level and patient illness severity, rather than patient volume. The observed teaching methods provide teachers who have high clinical productivity expectations and/or demanding emergency care settings with an enriched repertoire of teaching strategies.